Download PDF
Send Feedback
Home

Drawing Review & Management

Prepare for your Drawing Review & Management interview with these questions covering drawing checks, version control, and project coordination. Click on questions to view detailed answers.

Easy
Medium
Advanced
1
What is the main purpose of reviewing drawings in a construction project?
The main purpose of reviewing drawings is to make sure they are correct, complete, and coordinated before construction starts. This helps to:
  • Find Mistakes: Catch any errors or missing information early.
  • Prevent Problems: Avoid issues during construction that can cause delays and extra costs.
  • Ensure Safety: Make sure the design is safe and follows all rules.
  • Improve Quality: Help build a high-quality project.
In short, it's about making sure everyone builds the right thing, the right way.
2
Name two important things to check when reviewing a drawing.
Two important things to check when reviewing a drawing are:
  • Accuracy of Dimensions: Make sure all measurements are correct and match other related drawings. For example, check if the length of a wall on one drawing matches its length on another.
  • Clarity and Completeness: Ensure all necessary information is present and easy to understand. This includes notes, symbols, and details needed to build the structure.
Other important checks include coordination with other trades and compliance with standards.
3
Why is it important for different teams (like architects and engineers) to review drawings?
It's important for different teams (like architects, structural engineers, and MEP engineers) to review drawings because each team focuses on a different part of the building. This helps to:
  • Find Conflicts: Identify where different systems might clash (e.g., a pipe going through a structural beam).
  • Ensure Coordination: Make sure all parts of the design work together smoothly.
  • Catch Mistakes: Each team can spot errors related to their area of expertise that others might miss.
This teamwork helps create a complete and error-free design.
4
What is a "revision" on a drawing?
A "revision" on a drawing means a change or update has been made to it. When a drawing is revised, it gets a new revision number or letter (e.g., from Rev. A to Rev. B, or Rev. 0 to Rev. 1).
  • Why it happens: Changes can be due to design updates, client requests, site conditions, or corrections of errors.
  • Importance: Revisions help track changes and ensure everyone is working with the most current information.
Always check the revision number to confirm you have the latest drawing.
5
Why should you always use the latest version of a drawing?
You should always use the latest version of a drawing because it contains the most current and approved design information. Using an older version can lead to:
  • Building Mistakes: Constructing something incorrectly based on outdated information.
  • Rework: Having to demolish and rebuild parts of the structure, which costs time and money.
  • Safety Issues: Potentially building something unsafe if critical design changes are missed.
  • Delays and Conflicts: Causing confusion and arguments among teams.
Always confirm you have the latest revision before starting any work.
1
Explain the process of a typical drawing review cycle.
A typical drawing review cycle involves several steps to ensure accuracy and coordination:
  1. Drafting: The design team (e.g., architect, engineer) creates the initial drawing.
  2. Internal Review: The drawing is first reviewed by the creator's own team for basic correctness and completeness.
  3. Inter-disciplinary Review: The drawing is shared with other related teams (e.g., structural, MEP) for their comments and coordination checks. They look for clashes or inconsistencies.
  4. Client/Stakeholder Review: The drawing is sent to the client or other key parties for their feedback and approval.
  5. Comments & Revisions: All comments are collected. The design team then makes necessary changes and creates a new revision of the drawing.
  6. Re-submission & Approval: The revised drawing is resubmitted for final approval. This cycle repeats until all comments are addressed and the drawing is approved for construction.
This systematic process helps ensure a well-coordinated and approved design.
2
What are "clashes" in drawings, and how can they be avoided or resolved?

"Clashes" in drawings happen when two or more building components or systems are shown to occupy the same physical space. For example, a structural beam might be drawn where a large ventilation duct needs to pass, or a pipe might intersect with an electrical conduit.

How to Avoid:

  • Early Coordination: Architects, structural engineers, and MEP (Mechanical, Electrical, Plumbing) engineers should work together from the start.
  • Regular Review Meetings: Hold frequent meetings to discuss design elements and potential conflicts.
  • BIM (Building Information Modeling): Use BIM software, which can automatically detect clashes in a 3D model, making them easy to spot and fix before construction.

How to Resolve:

  • Identify the Clash: Pinpoint the exact location and components involved.
  • Discuss Solutions: The affected teams (e.g., structural and MEP) discuss possible ways to reroute, resize, or relocate one of the clashing elements.
  • Document Changes: Once a solution is agreed upon, update the drawings and issue a new revision.
Resolving clashes early saves significant time and money during construction.
3
How do you manage and control different versions of drawings on a project?
Managing and controlling different versions of drawings is crucial to avoid confusion and errors. This is usually done through a process called Document Control:
  • Centralized Storage: Keep all drawings in one main, easily accessible location, either a physical drawing office or, more commonly, a digital platform (like a Document Management System or Common Data Environment).
  • Naming Convention: Use a clear and consistent naming system for all drawings, including project number, drawing type, and revision number (e.g., PROJ-ARC-001-REV-A).
  • Revision Control: Every time a drawing is changed, give it a new revision number or letter. Old versions are kept for record but marked as "superseded" or "for information only."
  • Distribution Lists: Maintain a list of who receives which drawings, ensuring only the latest versions are distributed to those who need them for construction.
  • Access Control: Limit who can upload, modify, or approve drawings to prevent unauthorized changes.
Effective version control ensures everyone on the project is working with the correct and latest information.
4
What role does a "drawing register" play in project management?
A "drawing register" is a master list or log of all drawings related to a project. It acts as a central record and plays a vital role in project management by:
  • Tracking Status: Shows the current status of each drawing (e.g., "Issued for Review," "Approved," "Superseded").
  • Version Control: Records all revisions for each drawing, including revision numbers, dates, and a brief description of changes.
  • Accountability: Notes who issued the drawing, who received it, and who approved it.
  • Quick Reference: Allows project teams to quickly find specific drawings and their latest versions.
  • Audit Trail: Provides a historical record of all drawing activities, which is important for audits and resolving disputes.
It helps keep the project organized and ensures that everyone is working with the correct and up-to-date information.
5
Why is it important to have a clear process for approving drawings?
Having a clear process for approving drawings is very important because it:
  • Ensures Quality: Guarantees that drawings have been thoroughly checked and meet all project requirements and standards before they are used for construction.
  • Reduces Risk: Minimizes the chance of errors, rework, and costly delays during construction. An approved drawing means it's ready to be built from.
  • Assigns Responsibility: Clearly defines who is responsible for reviewing and approving each drawing, ensuring accountability.
  • Provides Legal Basis: Approved drawings serve as official documents for the project, important for contracts and legal purposes.
  • Facilitates Communication: A clear process ensures all relevant parties are involved in the review and approval, improving coordination.
Without a clear approval process, there's a high risk of building from incorrect or uncoordinated designs.
1
Discuss the impact of late drawing approvals or design changes on a construction project's schedule and cost.

Late drawing approvals or design changes can have a significant negative impact on a construction project's schedule and cost, creating a ripple effect across the entire project:

Impact on Schedule:

  • Delays in Procurement: Materials cannot be ordered until drawings are approved, leading to delays in material delivery.
  • Rework and Demolition: If construction has already started based on old drawings, new changes might require tearing down completed work, causing major delays.
  • Extended Construction Time: Overall project duration increases due to waiting for approvals or redoing work.
  • Loss of Productivity: Workers might be idle or moved to other tasks, reducing overall efficiency.

Impact on Cost:

  • Increased Labor Costs: Extended project time means more wages for workers, supervisors, and project management staff.
  • Material Waste: Materials ordered for the old design might become unusable, leading to waste and new material purchases.
  • Equipment Rental: Longer project duration means higher rental costs for machinery and equipment.
  • Penalty Clauses: Projects often have penalty clauses for late completion, leading to financial losses.
  • Administrative Overheads: Increased costs for managing changes, meetings, and additional documentation.
  • Subcontractor Claims: Subcontractors may submit claims for delays and additional work caused by changes.

To mitigate these impacts, proactive planning, clear communication, efficient review processes, and the use of digital tools are essential.

2
How can Building Information Modeling (BIM) improve the drawing review and management process?

Building Information Modeling (BIM) significantly improves the drawing review and management process by shifting from 2D drawings to a collaborative 3D model-based approach:

  • Automated Clash Detection: BIM software can automatically identify conflicts (clashes) between different building systems (architectural, structural, MEP) in the 3D model. This helps resolve issues digitally before they become costly problems on site.
  • Enhanced Visualization: 3D models are much easier to understand than 2D drawings, allowing all stakeholders (including clients and non-technical staff) to visualize the design clearly and provide more informed feedback during reviews.
  • Single Source of Truth: The BIM model acts as a central database for all project information. Any change made in the model automatically updates all related drawings, schedules, and quantities, ensuring consistency and accuracy.
  • Improved Coordination: All disciplines work on the same model, fostering better communication and coordination, reducing errors, and improving design quality.
  • Version Control & Audit Trail: Most BIM platforms have built-in document management features that track all changes, revisions, and approvals, providing a clear audit trail and ensuring everyone works on the latest version.
  • Faster Review Cycles: With automated checks and better visualization, review cycles can be much faster and more efficient.
  • Quantity Take-offs: BIM can automatically generate accurate material quantities, which helps in cost estimation and procurement.
BIM transforms the drawing review process from a sequential, manual task into an integrated, digital, and collaborative workflow, leading to fewer errors and more efficient projects.
3
Describe a systematic approach to identifying and resolving inconsistencies between architectural, structural, and MEP drawings.

A systematic approach to identifying and resolving inconsistencies (clashes) between architectural, structural, and MEP (Mechanical, Electrical, Plumbing) drawings is crucial for a smooth construction process. This often involves a multi-stage coordination process:

  1. Early & Continuous Coordination Meetings:
    • Start coordination early in the design phase, not just during drawing review.
    • Hold regular meetings with representatives from all disciplines (architectural, structural, MEP) to discuss design intent and potential conflicts.
  2. Utilize Building Information Modeling (BIM):
    • Model Integration: Combine individual discipline models (architectural, structural, MEP) into a single federated BIM model.
    • Automated Clash Detection: Use BIM software's built-in tools (e.g., Navisworks, Revit) to run automated clash detection reports. This identifies geometric conflicts where elements occupy the same space.
    • Visual Review: Conduct visual walk-throughs of the 3D model to spot non-geometric conflicts or areas of poor coordination that automated tools might miss.
  3. Structured Clash Resolution Workflow:
    • Clash Reporting: Generate detailed clash reports, usually from BIM software, identifying the clashing elements, their location, and the severity.
    • Assign Responsibility: Assign each clash to the responsible discipline(s) for resolution.
    • Coordination Meetings (Clash Detection Meetings): Hold dedicated meetings where affected teams discuss and propose solutions for each identified clash. Prioritize critical clashes.
    • Solution Implementation: The responsible discipline updates their model/drawing to resolve the clash.
    • Re-run Clash Detection: After changes, re-run clash detection to confirm the resolution and ensure no new clashes have been introduced.
  4. 2D Drawing Overlay & Manual Review (for non-BIM projects or additional checks):
    • Overlay drawings from different disciplines on a light table or digitally to visually identify misalignments or overlaps.
    • Manual cross-referencing of dimensions, levels, and clearances.
  5. Document & Track Resolutions:
    • Maintain a clear log of all clashes, their proposed solutions, responsible parties, and resolution status.
    • Ensure all resolved clashes are reflected in the updated, revised drawings.
This systematic, often BIM-driven, approach helps proactively manage design coordination, minimize errors, and reduce costly rework during construction.
4
What are the key elements of a robust document control system for drawings in a large-scale project?

A robust document control system for drawings in a large-scale project is essential for efficiency, accuracy, and legal compliance. Its key elements include:

  1. Centralized Common Data Environment (CDE):
    • A single, secure digital platform (e.g., SharePoint, Aconex, Procore) where all project documents, including drawings, are stored. This ensures everyone accesses the same information.
  2. Standardized Naming Convention:
    • A strict, consistent naming system for all drawings (e.g., Project Code-Discipline-Type-Sequence Number-Revision). This makes it easy to find and identify drawings.
  3. Version Control & Revision Management:
    • Automated tracking of all drawing revisions. Each change results in a new revision number/letter. Old versions are archived but clearly marked as "Superseded" or "For Information Only."
    • A clear audit trail showing who made changes, when, and why.
  4. Drawing Register/Master Document List:
    • A comprehensive log of every drawing, its current revision, status (e.g., Issued for Construction, Approved), issue date, and responsible party.
  5. Workflow for Review & Approval:
    • Defined steps for submitting, reviewing, commenting on, and approving drawings, with clear roles and responsibilities for each stage.
    • Automated notifications for pending actions.
  6. Access Control & Permissions:
    • Strict control over who can view, edit, upload, or approve drawings based on their role and need.
  7. Transmittal Management:
    • Formal records of when drawings are sent to external parties (e.g., contractors, clients), ensuring clear communication and accountability for what was received.
  8. Archiving & Retention Policy:
    • A plan for storing historical versions of drawings and retaining project documentation for legal and operational purposes long after project completion.
  9. Training & Compliance:
    • Ensuring all project team members are trained on the document control system and adhere to its procedures.
Such a system minimizes errors, improves collaboration, and supports legal and contractual obligations throughout the project lifecycle.
5
How do you ensure that subcontractors and suppliers are working with the correct and latest versions of drawings?

Ensuring subcontractors and suppliers use the correct and latest drawings is critical to avoid costly mistakes and delays. This requires a proactive and systematic approach:

  1. Centralized Document Management System (DMS) / CDE:
    • Provide subcontractors and suppliers with access to a single, centralized digital platform. This is the only official source for drawings.
    • Ensure they are trained on how to navigate and download documents from this system.
  2. Formal Transmittals:
    • Always issue drawings to subcontractors and suppliers via formal transmittals. These documents should clearly list the drawing numbers, revision numbers, issue dates, and their purpose (e.g., "Issued for Construction," "For Information Only").
    • Require acknowledgment of receipt for critical drawings.
  3. Automated Notifications:
    • Set up the DMS to automatically notify relevant parties when new revisions of drawings they are working with are uploaded.
  4. Regular Site Checks / Audits:
    • Periodically check the drawings being used by site teams (subcontractors' foremen, supervisors) to ensure they match the latest versions in the DMS.
    • Conduct "drawing walks" to verify that work being done matches the current approved drawings.
  5. Clear Communication Protocol for Changes:
    • Establish a clear process for communicating design changes. This might involve mandatory site meetings to discuss significant revisions.
    • Highlight changes on new revisions (e.g., clouds and revision triangles on the drawing, or a revision table).
  6. "Superseded" Marking:
    • When a new revision is issued, clearly mark older versions as "Superseded" in the DMS and ensure physical copies are removed from circulation on site.
  7. Contractual Obligations:
    • Include clauses in contracts that mandate subcontractors and suppliers to work only from the latest issued drawings and to maintain their own document control procedures.
By implementing these measures, project management can significantly reduce the risk of working with outdated information, leading to smoother execution and better project outcomes.
×

Thank You!

Thanks for your feedback User. We'll review your suggestions.